I was stupidier than I thought.
I thought that the bad guys nailed me on 6/6/2008. But in reviewing the information on the files that were dumped on the box on that day was a file called KB1920213.log, they nailed me earlier than I thought they did. Which points out the stupid thing I did. I was not monitoring the system truly as well as I should have. The installer process on this box was not being monitored by me. If I had been I would have noticed that back in May (the log file date of 4/14 appears to be incorrect based on other evidence) was when they really broke in via the php file in Merak email software.
The mitigation I have in place now is two fold, first all ports are limited (with the exception of port 80, 443 and 25). The port that they nailed me on, port 32000 is no longer open to all listserve administrators from any location. This means the balancing act between security and functionality as I find a happy medium. Secondly I now have EventSentry on the box so that if someone sneezes near it, I'm alerted.
But this points out the fact that a restore from a backup from a date you think the bad guys got in may not be the right date. If I had merely gone from the intial evidence I saw, that date would have been 6/6/2008. Now with this additional evidence, that date is (edit) 5/15/2008 5/14/2008. Furthermore, one has to be a tad paranoid to look at the data I put back. Given the manner in which the server is set up, I am reasonably confident that the data was not mangled with. But it sure does give one pause, doesn't it?
When the bad guys script and leave behind log files so that their system is set up properly...it just puts a lot more paranoia in one, doesn't it?
Anatomy Of A Hack: How A Criminal Might Infiltrate Your Network:
http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/magazine/cc160808.aspx
Read that and think about what holes there are in your security stance. There definitely was holes in mine.
Computer Date_Time Source Text
YODA 2008-06-06 05:40:16 FSInfo_C_NTFS.csv Last Write: C:\WINDOWS\KB1920213.log


Coded by: SlaYeR and COLdGiN
And Many thanks to Bullet! our big ass teamleader! Version 1.0
[Xcacls.exe is redownloaded!]
Kit started date: Wed May 14 13:13:10 2008
+================+
+ Version 1.0 +
+================+
[Scanning for Anti-Virus applications...]
+================+
+ Systeminfo +
+================+
OS: Windows 2003 [vesion 5.2.3790] Service Pack 2
Host Name:YODA
Windows Dir:(C:\WINDOWS)
System Dir:(C:\WINDOWS\system32)
Uptime: 0d 16h 23m 3s
Total CPU cores:2
System speed: 2813 Mhz
RAM Usage: 1545/2032 MB (76%)
+----------------------------------------------------------+
C:\ Name:()Total:35291.MB->34.GB Free:13566.MB->13.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
D:\ Name:(New Volume)Total:238464.MB->232.GB Free:139778.MB->136.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
E:\ Name:()Total:476929.MB->465.GB Free:432612.MB->422.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
F:\ Name:(WD Passport)Total:57215.MB->55.GB Free:35055.MB->34.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
+----------------------------------------------------------+
[2008-4-14 13:13:11] --> [Hello! ^^ I'm Ph0eniX and I'm installing your files..]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [Verrry Niice ^^ Windows File Protection has been disabled!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [O Oh ^^ Real SysmonLog service deleted!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [smlogsvc.exe Deleted!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [smlogsvc.exe copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [arper.exe copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [aproman.exe copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [sysmem.dll copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [memdump.dll copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:12] --> [Fake smlogsvc.exe loaded!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:13] --> [smlogsvc.exe started!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:13] --> [Sysmon.exe copyed to system32!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:13] --> [serv-u body service created!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:14] --> [Yay ^^ Service corectly created for the serv-u]
[2008-4-14 13:13:15] --> [Happy Time ^^ Sysmon.exe started!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:17] --> [start.exe cleaned!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:17] --> [firewall.reg cleaned!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:17] --> [arper.exe cleaned!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:17] --> [xcacls.exe cleaned!]
[2008-4-14 13:13:19] --> [See you in hell ^^ i'm committing suicide bye bye!]

Coded by: SlaYeR and COLdGiN
And Many thanks to Bullet! our big ass teamleader! Version 1.0
[Xcacls.exe is redownloaded!]
Kit started date: Fri Jun 06 05:40:07 2008
+================+
+ Version 1.0 +
+================+
[Scanning for Anti-Virus applications...]
+================+
+ Systeminfo +
+================+
OS: Windows 2003 [vesion 5.2.3790] Service Pack 2
Host Name:YODA
Windows Dir:(C:\WINDOWS)
System Dir:(C:\WINDOWS\system32)
Uptime: 23d 8h 49m 29s
Total CPU cores:2
System speed: 2813 Mhz
RAM Usage: 1485/2032 MB (73%)
+----------------------------------------------------------+
C:\ Name:()Total:35291.MB->34.GB Free:13100.MB->12.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
D:\ Name:(New Volume)Total:238464.MB->232.GB Free:128084.MB->125.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
E:\ Name:()Total:476929.MB->465.GB Free:190009.MB->185.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
F:\ Name:(WD Passport)Total:57215.MB->55.GB Free:256.MB->0.GB Type:NTFS Source:LOCAL
+----------------------------------------------------------+
[2008-5-6 5:40:8] --> [Hello! ^^ I'm Ph0eniX and I'm installing your files..]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [Verrry Niice ^^ Windows File Protection has been disabled!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [O Oh ^^ Real SysmonLog service deleted!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [Cannot delete smlogsvc.exe! still running?]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [smlogsvc.exe Failed to copy to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [arper.exe copyed to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [aproman.exe Failed to copy to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [sysmem.dll Failed to copy to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [memdump.dll Failed to copy to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:9] --> [Fake smlogsvc.exe loaded!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [smlogsvc.exe started!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [Heey! old serv-u found! reinstalling the serv-u!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [Failed to kill real Sysmon.exe!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [Cannot delete Sysmon.exe! still running?]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [Sysmon.exe Failed to copy to system32!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [serv-u body service created!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:10] --> [Yay ^^ Service corectly created for the serv-u]
[2008-5-6 5:40:11] --> [Happy Time ^^ Sysmon.exe started!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:14] --> [start.exe cleaned!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:14] --> [firewall.reg cleaned!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:14] --> [arper.exe cleaned!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:14] --> [xcacls.exe cleaned!]
[2008-5-6 5:40:16] --> [See you in hell ^^ i'm committing suicide bye bye!]